Italian Restaurant in West Islip, NY

Over 30 Different Slices

Fast Service and Delivery

Gluten-Free Options Available

Visit Us

Hours:

Request Catering

Hero Request Form

A black and white icon of a hat on a white background.

Savor Authentic Italian Flavors at Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta

Craving a slice of Italy right here on Long Island? Look no further than Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta. We're passionate about bringing the rich, mouthwatering tastes of traditional Italian cuisine to West Islip, Bay Shore, Babylon, North Babylon, and West Babylon. Our commitment to quality ingredients, time-honored recipes, and exceptional service has made us a beloved local favorite. We're amongst the top pizzerias on Slice and Uber Eats, as well as a most-loved restaurant on DoorDash.


Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty pasta dish, or one of our innovative specialty slices, we've got something to satisfy every palate. With over 30 different slice options, you'll always find something new and exciting to try. Come experience the warmth of Italian hospitality and the comfort of delicious food at Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta. Enjoy a delicious meal and visit us today.

A chef is standing next to a table with plates and bowls of food.

Get a Sneak Peek at What We're Cooking Up for You!

A pizza with cheese on top of it is on a pan on a counter.
A large slice of pizza is sitting on a metal tray.
A man in a green shirt is looking at a pizza on a tray.
A slice of pizza with a sign that says grandma on it
A variety of pastries are displayed in a glass case.
A pizza is sitting on a metal pan on a counter.
View More Dishes

Menu

We offer an extensive selection of pizzas, from classic Neapolitan-style to innovative gourmet creations. Our pasta dishes showcase the diversity of Italian cuisine, featuring both traditional favorites and chef's specialties. Don't forget to explore our appetizers and salads for a complete Italian dining experience.

Learn More

Catering Menu

Planning an event? Our catering menu brings the flavors of Italy to your special occasions. We offer a wide range of options, from party-sized pizzas and pasta trays to appetizer platters and dessert selections. Our catering menu is designed to accommodate gatherings of all sizes, ensuring your guests enjoy a memorable feast.

Learn More

Catering Service

Let us take the stress out of event planning with our professional catering service. Our experienced team will work closely with you to create a customized menu that suits your event's needs and budget. From setup to cleanup, we handle every detail, allowing you to focus on enjoying your event with your guests.

Learn More
A black and white icon of a speech bubble on a white background.

Here's what our satisfied customers are saying...

At Our Little Italy Pizza Pasta, we take pride in providing exceptional pizza and pasta to our customers. We would be grateful if you could share your thoughts about our restaurant with others. Your feedback helps us improve and helps others make informed decisions. Please take a moment to leave a review of Our Little Italy Pizza Pasta and let others know what you think.